By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support great journalism.
As insurance premiums soar after Katrina, some homeowners are going bare
Katrina Insurance J 6979536
State Insurance Commissioner George Dale tells reporters at a Monday, March 19, 2007, news conference, in Jackson, Miss., that State Farm Fire & Casualty Co. has agreed to re-examine more than 35,000 policyholder claims filed following Hurricane Katrina and to "make millions of dollars available" for additional payments. Dale said the agreement would cover homeowners, renters and commercial claims in Harrison, Hancock and Jackson counties, including those that are in mediation and those that are the subject of pending litigation. - photo by Associated Press
NEW ORLEANS — Disgusted with his insurance company after Hurricane Katrina, the Rev. Simmie Harvey let his homeowner policy lapse and left his house in the hands of a higher power.
    Somebody up there must like the 88-year-old Baptist minister: His newly uninsured house escaped serious damage last month when a tornado ripped through the city’s Uptown neighborhood and toppled a tree that narrowly missed his home.
    ‘‘I wasn’t lucky. I’m blessed,’’ he said. ‘‘I’m going to be all right. The Lord takes care of me.’’
    Facing soaring premiums or feeling shortchanged by their insurers, a growing number of homeowners and businesses in Louisiana and Mississippi are ‘‘going bare,’’ or dropping their coverage altogether, insurance agents and consumer advocates say. Many more are drastically reducing their coverage.
    ‘‘I have every belief that it’s going to be more and more common,’’ said Amy Bach, executive director of the United Policyholders advocacy group. ‘‘If it’s a choice between eating or paying their insurance bills, of course they’re going to eat.’’
    With the new hurricane season beginning June 1, it is a risky strategy. These people could lose everything in a storm or some kind of tragic accident around the house.
    ‘‘You’re basically playing Russian roulette with your most valuable asset,’’ said Robert Hartwig, president and chief economist of the Insurance Information Institute, an industry-funded group.
    Elderly homeowners — particularly those on fixed incomes and those who have paid off their mortgages — may be the most likely to go uninsured. Most homeowners don’t have that choice, because mortgage companies require borrowers to have insurance. Those whose homes are paid off can drop their policies, unless they are getting government grants or loans that require one.
    ‘‘Definitely, you’ll be seeing more of this,’’ said Bennett Powell, a Metairie insurance agent whose firm sold Harvey his policy.
    Exactly how many policyholders are going bare is unclear. The insurance commissioners in Mississippi and Louisiana are not keeping track, and insurers say they do not how many of their former customers are simply buying new policies from a different company.
    Shopping around can also be a risky strategy, because homeowners in Louisiana who switch are no longer protected by a state law that bars insurers from canceling policies that have been in effect for three years or longer.
    ‘‘Do not shop,’’ said Louisiana Insurance Commissioner Jim Donelon. ‘‘That protection outweighs the advantage of shopping, in my opinion.’’
    Homeowner insurance typically covers wind damage from hurricanes, as well as damage to the home from fires, auto accidents and other misfortunes. It also protects a homeowner if someone gets injured on the property. Along the Gulf Coast, flood insurance is sold separately from homeowner insurance, and made available thorugh a federal program.
    Robert Page, a Houma, La.-based insurance agent and president-elect of the National Association of Professional Insurance Agents, said the owners of three large apartment complexes in Houma recently dropped their wind and hail coverage after their premiums doubled. Page said only a few of his thousands of customers have gone completely bare after Katrina.
    But ‘‘it’s only the beginning,’’ he said. ‘‘In my opinion, it’s going to get worse before it gets better.’’
    Harvey, whose modest ranch-style house has a neat lawn and a long driveway for his black Cadillac, rode out Katrina in his home during the summer of 2005 and only briefly evacuated the city in the storm’s chaotic aftermath.
    His roughly $1,800 annual premium did not increase significantly after Katrina, but he said he elected to drop his Farmers Insurance Co. policy because the company paid him about $4,000 even though he blames the wind for about $10,000 in damage to his roof.
    ‘‘If that’s all I can get, I don’t have any need to get insurance,’’ he said, figuring he is better off saving his money than paying premiums.
    In Louisiana, insurance companies raised their homeowner rates an average of 13.2 percent in 2006, according to Amy Whittington, spokeswoman for the Louisiana Insurance Department. Some insurers went far higher.
    Many small business owners are feeling the sharpest pinch. The insurer of last resort for many Mississippi homeowners and businesses is the state’s ‘‘wind pool,’’ and its commercial rates have jumped 268 percent since Katrina.
    Tom Simmons, who owns three office buildings in Gulfport, Miss., said he paid $3,070 in premiums for the rental properties before Katrina. Maintaining that level of coverage this year would cost more than $25,000, he said.
    Simmons is considering dropping his wind and hail policies but holding onto his fire and liability coverage. Even though none of his properties flooded during Katrina, the thought of heading into the next storm season without wind coverage is ‘‘scary as hell.’’
    ‘‘The whole darn area is facing this sort of thing,’’ he said. ‘‘The insurance companies obviously want out. Maybe they’re just pricing us out of the market rather than just saying they’re leaving the state.’’
    Jeffrey O’Keefe, president of the Bradford-O’Keefe Funeral Homes on Mississippi’s Gulf Coast, already has scaled back his coverage.
    Before Katrina, he paid $61,224 in annual premiums to insure five funeral homes, two cemeteries and a crematorium. Renewing that $7 million in coverage would have cost about $781,000, so he reduced his coverage to $2 million. But he is still paying $122,113 in premiums, twice as much as before the storm.
    ‘‘As a small business owner, it’s really putting a hurt on us,’’ he said. ‘‘It’s a bad problem.’’
Sign up for the Herald's free e-newsletter