By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support great journalism.
After crash, Hoboken residents ponder God and fate
1c140f1e4fe33cfa55cc377efecbb7012f8ce26969b689ef46bc3c3b567de666
As investigators look into what caused the New Jersey Transits Pascack Valley commuter train to enter the station at high speed on Thursday, some residents of this New York suburb ponder what role God and fate play in such tragedies. - photo by Chris Sagona
HOBOKEN, N.J. In the basement of Hoboken Gospel Chapel three blocks from the train terminal, about a dozen church members sat at bingo tables, eyes closed, heads bowed, hands folded over their open Bibles, giving thanks to God and praying for the victims of Thursdays commuter rail crash.

We know that even when there are tragedies, there is always good. And even when there are accidents, there are always things to be thankful for, prayed church elder Brian Hoffert hours after the crash.

As investigators look into what caused the New Jersey Transits Pascack Valley commuter train to enter the station at high speed on Thursday, some residents of this New York suburb ponder what role God and fate play in such tragedies.

Gospel Chapel member Richard Pasquale said that while one women was killed and more than 100 people were injured, the fact that there werent more fatalities was a sign of God at work.

Its all Gods grace, he said. While he allows tragedies to happen, ultimately its his grace, that allows us to come through it.

Moshe Shapiro, a Chabad rabbi who is a chaplain with the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, believes God was present.

It is very, very, very tragic that a woman died, he said. But Ive been at the train station and thirty people are at that same spot on other days.

One death is one too many but just to look at how a train stops and a few hundred people get off, and sometimes a few at one time go left to the Path (commuter trains), others go right to the light rail. It could have been so much worse.

But others viewed things differently.

Near the station, Brianna Stimpson and her boyfriend embraced on the sidewalk in front of where they live.

After things like this happen people tend to frequently say thank God for controlling things, she said. But then you find out after accidents like this, oh, its actually the guy who stays awake while driving, that saves you. And its the people who keep your heat on, your lights on, who get you safely across the street, its some guy who you find out is 10 miles away from you, but whos been keeping you safe all along and you never said thank you, because you didnt even know he was doing things to keep you safe.

Stimpson said those people should get the credit.

You know how much love and kindness there would be in the world, if every time someone said thank you God, they also always said thank you to everyone around them? I mean, think about it, she said.

Like many New York area residents, Hobokenites have been thinking a lot about fate since the Sept. 11 attacks.

Commuter Jean OReilly said she could have had the same end as Fabiola de Kroon, 34, who died in the crash.

I walked that same pathway as Fabiola, just about an hour and a half earlier than her today, she said. Everyday I walk down Washington Street, then theres a path along the river, where there are always police along the river with guns at the ready for terrorism. You get used to seeing that. Then this happens.

Michael Scelzo of Oradell, N.J., was in the first car and watched beams come into the train and the first rows collapse in front of him.

Running through my mind was, I dont know if Im going to make it out of this,' said Scelzo, who has a big bruise and a dried gash under his eye. Im a Catholic, not a practicing Catholic. Im very practical. I do believe in God and in fate and it could have been so much worse.

Im not sure what the reason for this is, he went on. I will say I truly came out of this appreciating life more today than yesterday. Im more aware of my surroundings and more thankful for things I would not otherwise have noticed. It was an accident and life happens and Im thankful.
Sign up for the Herald's free e-newsletter