View Mobile Site

Vintage suffrage: Women to judge wine in national competition

SANTA ROSA, Calif. — Women buy much of the wine purchased in the United States, and they make quite a bit of it too. But it’s mostly male critics who proclaim what’s prime and what’s plonk.
    Enter the National Women’s Wine Competition being held this month in Northern California. The event, judged entirely by women, boldly sports the slogan ‘‘Wine Women Want.’’ There’s even a separate category of entries from women winemakers to add an extra fillip of vintage suffrage.
    The competition runs March 13-15 in Santa Rosa, and interest in being a single-gender contender has been keen. Wineries from across the country responded and about 1,800 entries have come in, more than double expectations.
    ‘‘We seem to have hit a nerve,’’ said organizer Lea Pierce.
    Having an all-woman panel is a departure for the wine industry, where judging remains largely a man’s world, something Pierce and others attribute more to slowly changing trends in the wine industry than overt discrimination.
    Organizers believe this is the first contest judged by an all-woman panel in the United States. An international competition to be judged by women is planned in April in Monaco.
    ‘‘Women want to be recognized. They want to have their own venue,’’ said Pierce. ‘‘I do think it’s very important, long-term, to raise up a new set of women critics.’’
    The competition began as a ‘‘bolt from the blue,’’ during a conversation about wine contests in general a few years ago, said Pierce, co-owner of an advertising agency and member of a networking group called Women for WineSense.
    ‘‘At that point, I’d been in the wine industry for a couple of years, I was really aware of how many women are involved in wine and how it was growing. It was just sort of this insight that it would be a good thing to showcase women,’’ she said.
    Months of organizing followed.
    ‘‘The phone calls have just been fabulous,’’ said Pierce. ‘‘Big wineries, little wineries. One woman called, she said, ’I’m so psyched about this. My mom has been making wines for 30 years and it’s about time she got some recognition.’’’
    Co-chairs of the competition are Margrit Mondavi, a longtime force in wine country and wife of pioneering vintner Robert Mondavi, and Kathryn Hall, a former ambassador to Austria and a Napa Valley vintner.
    Contestants include Marcia Monahan, winemaker at Pelton House, a new winery in the Knight’s Valley region of Sonoma County. She’s entering a 2004 cabernet sauvignon and 2004 merlot in three categories, including the women winemaker’s challenge division. ‘‘It’s fabulous that women are getting together to evaluate and judge wine,’’ she said.
    Is there a difference between male and female palates?
    Linda Bisson, a professor in the wine department of the University of California, Davis, hasn’t seen much of a gender gap in her years of teaching, although she liked the idea of bringing more women to the judging table.
    Leslie Sbrocco, author of ‘‘Wine for Women,’’ doesn’t think there’s a ‘‘male’’ or ‘‘female’’ palate, but that doesn’t mean there’s no distinction.
    ‘‘It’s not about the female palate being different. It’s about the female perspective being different,’’ said Sbrocco.
    Wilfred Wong, cellar master for Beverages & More, a California retail liquor chain, remembers when wine contests were the province of ‘‘codgers and good old boys.’’ That started to change in the ’90s with the judging becoming much more competitive and the emphasis shifting to using professionals, including some of the increasing numbers of women making and critiquing wine, he said.
    Having an all-woman judging panel is intriguing, said Wong, although he’s wary about drawing too many conclusions from the results.
    Pierce agreed and said the point of the competition is to demonstrate ‘‘what these women think is good. It’s really about a bunch of women with great palates recommending wine to other women.’’
    Women want to be recognized, said Pierce. And, she added, ‘‘people want to know what wine women want. Especially men.’’
    ———
    On the Net: http://www.nwwc.info

Interested in viewing premium content?

A subscription is required before viewing this article and other premium content.

Already a registered member and have a subscription?

If you have already purchased a subscription, please log in to view the full article.

Are you registered, but do not have a subscription?

If you are a registed user and would like to purchase a subscription, log in to view a list of available subscriptions.

Interested in becoming a registered member and purchasing a subscription?

Join our community today by registering for a FREE account. Once you have registered for a FREE account, click SUBSCRIBE NOW to purchase access to premium content.

Membership Benefits

  • Instant access to creating Blogs, Photo Albums, and Event listings.
  • Email alerts with the latest news.
  • Access to commenting on articles.

Please wait ...